Andrea Cummings Kubik was inducted into the Ohio Dominican University Hall of Fame in 2011. Cummings Kubik was a first-team All-Mid Ohio Conference softball player and was named the 1990 Mid Ohio Conference Pitcher of the Year. In 1991, she made 23 starts, throwing a complete game in 21 of them. Cummings Kubik won 18 of those games, earning herself an honorable mention NAIA All-District 22 selection. She earned the same honor in 1993, along with being honorable mention All-Mid Ohio Conference.